It's starting at primary school level now

Here we go again. The start of the rugby season is still a month away and already we have one school refusing to play another. It’s about player poaching, again, and while it’s disappointing, no-one should really be surprised.

The schools involved, DHS and Glenwood, have been grouchy neighbours up on the Berea for a long time and Glenwood can’t seem to keep away from this kind of controversy. There’s been a perception for a while now that the school looks for talented players in other places and tries to lure them to their ranks. I don’t know whether that’s true or not, but certainly none of the top schools in Joburg will play any kind of sport against them. It’s not the first time DHS has called off relations, for the same reason.

So, not an original story. What’s different this time is the age group level at which this one is playing out. The boys involved are in grade 8 – 13 year-olds - and, it seems, deals were done and money was paid during their primary school years already.

There’s a memorandum of understanding that was signed by the heads of the boys-only schools to the effect that they will not approach players who are at other schools. It’s well-intentioned, although it’s significant that most of the recent well-publicised controversies, including this one, involve schools that are signatories to the agreement.

That said, there seems to be an acceptance that when it comes to grade 7s deciding on which high school they will be going to, the gloves are off and it’s an open market that everyone can participate in. OK, but I have expressed the (very much minority) opinion that at such a young age in particular, educational and ethical values should still apply. I have been to the under-13 Craven Week and seen the talent scouts from the top (and wannabee top) schools standing on the touchlines, clipboards in hand and cheque books in the back pocket, running their eyes over the young flesh on display like trainers and breeders at the thoroughbred yearling sales.

It was only a matter of time before things went awry and these practices hit the headlines.

What happened In Durban is happening in other places too. Briefly, DHS paid for the schooling at Glenwood Prep (unfortunately named, it turned out), of two KZN Primary Schools rugby players on the understanding that they will go to DHS in grade 8. They reneged and are at Glenwood Boys’ High now, hence the outrage.

In the face of the fierce competition for the top primary school players, the recruitment people at the high schools have to act quickly to sign the right 13-year olds up, and they need to have the right deals to offer. A way of getting around that is to get in 1^st and seal a commitment while the child is in grade 7, or even in grade 6. Pay for his primary schooling and contract him to come to your high school eventually.

Now, I’m totally in agreement with the principle of offering financial assistance to needy parents who cannot afford to send their talented offspring to a good school. I’ll even go along with the idea of funding primary school education with the aim of giving a bright young child a solid grounding so that he or she has a better chance of success in secondary school.

That’s not what’s happening with these rugby players. This is the win-at-all-costs attitude sinking to new moral depths. The practice should be outlawed and no-one should play against schools who subscribe to it, whether they are enrolling the children they have groomed themselves, or stolen them from someone else.